Access Points vs. Wireless Extenders: Enhancing Your Wi-Fi Network

In today's interconnected world, a robust Wi-Fi network is essential for both personal and professional use in domestic and commercial settings. As the demand for ubiquitous connectivity grows, understanding the tools available to enhance your wireless network becomes crucial. Two common solutions for expanding Wi-Fi coverage without the need for a second broadband router are wireless access points (WAP) and wireless extenders. While they serve a similar purpose, they function differently and are suitable for distinct scenarios. This article delves into the differences between access points and wireless extenders, helping you choose the right solution for your needs.

Understanding Access Points

What Are Access Points?

An access point (AP) is a device that creates a new wireless local area network (WLAN) or can be used to extend an existing one. It connects to a wired router, switch, or hub via an Ethernet cable, typically Cat5e or Cat6 and provides Wi-Fi to a designated area. Wireless access points are often used in larger homes or commercial businesses premises to offer a more extensive and stable Wi-Fi network.

Advantages of Access Points:

1. Scalability: Access points can support multiple devices without significantly affecting performance. This makes them ideal for large offices, schools, or public spaces. A single network can be extended with multiple WIFI access points.
2. Coverage: By strategically placing multiple access points, you can create a seamless network with extensive coverage, eliminating dead zones and black spots.
3. Performance: Access points typically offer better performance and higher speeds compared to extenders. They can handle a large number of simultaneous connections efficiently. Wireless Access Points are full duplex, which means that can support two way communication at the same time resulting in 100% efficiency.
4. Flexibility: Many access points come with advanced features like VLAN support, multiple SSIDs, guest networks, and enhanced security protocols, providing greater control over your network making them perfect for schools, hotels or anywhere where security is paramount.

Disadvantages of Access Points:

1. Complexity: Setting up access points can be more complex and may require some networking knowledge as data cabling may be need to be installed.
2. Cost: Access points tend to be more expensive than extenders, both in terms of the devices themselves and potential installation costs if professional help is required.

Understanding Wireless Extenders

What Are Wireless Extenders?

Wireless extenders, also known as repeaters or boosters, amplify the existing Wi-Fi signal to reach areas where the signal is weak. They are usually very easy to set up and are typically used in smaller homes or spaces where Wi-Fi coverage is spotty. It's usually just a case pressing a button to link the equipment.

Advantages of Wireless Extenders:

1. Ease of Use: Wireless extenders are straightforward to install and configure. Most devices come with a simple setup process that doesn't require technical expertise.
2. Affordability: Extenders are generally more affordable than access points, making them a cost-effective solution for improving Wi-Fi coverage.
3. Convenience: They are compact and can be plugged into any power outlet, providing flexibility in terms of placement. No extra cabling is required.

Disadvantages of Wireless Extenders:

1. Performance: Extenders can reduce overall network performance. Since they rebroadcast the signal, the extended network may experience decreased speeds and increased latency. Wireless extenders are half-duplex meaning that although they do support two way communications, this can not be done at the same time reducing throughput by 50%.
2. Coverage Limitations: While extenders improve coverage, they are not as effective in large areas or spaces with many obstacles, such as thick walls or multiple floors. Hopping a signal between two or more wireless repeaters reduces the efficiency by half each time. Extenders should be positioned in a place that is roughly in between the existing Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN) that you wish to expand and where you intend to use it. Too close either end could result in a connection that doesn't work.
3. Interference: Extenders are prone to interference from other electronic devices, which can affect their performance.

Choosing the Right Solution

The choice between access points and wireless extenders depends on several factors, including the size of the area you need to cover, your budget, and the performance requirements of your network.

• For Large Spaces and High Performance: Access points are the better choice. They offer more reliable coverage, higher performance, and scalability, making them ideal for large homes, offices, or public areas with heavy network usage. They can be connected to an existing wired network and expanded to cover large distances.
• For Small to Medium Spaces and Ease of Use: Wireless extenders are suitable for smaller homes or areas where you need a quick and easy solution to eliminate Wi-Fi dead zones. They are cost-effective and simple to set up, though they may not provide the same level of performance as access points. If you have a very fast internet connection, like a Full Fibre connection it may not be an issue a 50% throughput loss on the wireless connection.
• Hybrid Solutions: It's possible to combine the benefits of wireless access points and WIFI range extenders, for example for optimum performance you amy wish to install a network with multiple access points, but have a problem routing a cable to a position where a further WIFI extension is required. A wireless extender could be utilised in this situation creating a hybrid solution.

Wireless Bridges & Powerline Adapters

To compliment this article, we will brief you on two further alternatives. A wireless bridge acts similar to a WIFI range extender but with the added benefit of allowing the wired network to be extended after the bridge. Powerline adapters plug into an existing electrical socket and utilise existing mains electrical cabling to distribute data signals. The typically come in a pair, one that connects between your broadband router and powerline adapter with an Ethernet cable and a second adapter that connects to your device with a second Ethernet cable. Powerline networks can sometimes be extended to communicate to more than two powerline adapters. Powerline adapters can be obtained to an extension of the wireless network too. It's important when installing these than the powerlnes are both connected to the same electical circuit so that they can communicate together. This can be problematic with modern wiring where it's common to balance the electrical load to install multiple circuits in the same house preventing powerline adapters from being effecive

Conclusion

Enhancing your Wi-Fi network can significantly improve your internet experience, whether at home or in a professional setting. Access points and wireless extenders each have their strengths and weaknesses, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision. If you need extensive coverage and robust performance, investing in access points is the way to go. For smaller spaces with a focus on simplicity and cost-effectiveness, wireless extenders offer a practical solution. Assess your specific needs and choose the option that best aligns with your requirements to enjoy a seamless and efficient wireless network.

‍